Compare and Contrast the Views of Native Americans and Europeans

Topics: Religion, Family, India Pages: 3 (913 words) Published: January 24, 2002
During the 16th and 17th centuries, when the Europeans started to come over to the new world, they discovered a society of Indians that was strikingly different to their own. To understand how different, one must first compare and contrast some of the very important differences between them, such as how the Europeans considered the Indians to be extremely primitive and basic, while, considering themselves civilized. The Europeans considered that they were model societies, and they thought that the Indians society and culture should be changed to be very similar to their own.

The Europeans and the Indians had very contrasting ideas of personal wealth and ownership. The Europeans believed that only the rich should own land, and strongly followed the practice that when you passed away, the land stays in the family to keep the family honor and pride alive. In European society, what one owned decided one's identity, political standpoint, wealth, and even independence. The Indians believed that property was part of a tribe, not a personal possession to own. One of their beliefs was that the land was sacred, and each family should have a piece of the whole. As a general rule, the Indians followed their belief that states that everything on the earth is given to all, and each person deserves their own share. In 1657, a French Jesuit said that, "Their kindness, humanity and courtesy not only makes them liberal with what they have, but causes them to possess hardly anything except in common."

In European society during the time of colonization, the man was by far more important in society than his wife. For Europeans, the to be a member of a family you had to be related to the eldest male in the household. This was a total opposite to the Indian society. For example, in the Iroquois society, family membership was determined by the family of the female. At the head of each family was an elder woman, followed by her daughter, their husbands and children,...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • European Views of Native Americans Essay

    ...The trappers of the Canadian wilderness and the American wilderness liked and respected Native Americans. They even interbred with them and sold them guns, which was very often illegal. Traders had a special status in Native American society. A trader could travel thousands of miles in his canoe without once being robbed or molested. Contrast that with Europe, where anyone from another town was fair game. However, the English settlers, after a very brief period of good relations in Massachusetts, came to loathe Native Americans. There was a serious culture clash here between stone age Native Americans (who had no land as private property, property belonged variously to the family, clan, or tribe) and Iron Age Europeans. Europeans had a totally different concept of private property. Your own property could be sold, transferred, deeded, or abused with complete contempt for the land. It astonished Native Americans that the English and Dutch could denude, or even want to denude,entire mountains of forest in just a few years. To them this was incredibly barbaric. In European eyes Native Americans were contemptible because they embraced polygamy, often went about nude, and indulged in mutilating corpses after a battle. Usually this meant...

    Read More
    1070 Words 5 Pages
  • Compare/Contrast Native Americans/ Black Africans Essay

    ...example, the Europeans ushered an era of war upon their homelands. In addition, Europeans also denounced most of their culture, traditions, and practices as inferior to those of Europeans. For example, their religions and cultures were considered inferior so they were Christianized and westernized, respectively. Traditionally, both the Sub-Saharan and Native American religions bear similar characteristics. For example, they both believe in the idea of a creator god with supporting, lesser gods. In addition, both cultures believe in animism and the importance of a burial, burial rites, and rituals. Also, within these rituals, both cultures stressed the importance of music: since neither culture had a written language until the advent of Islam or the Europeans, music was the usually the only way to communicate with their ancestors. Animism is a common concept among both religions. It is believed that nature had living spirit that could be communicated with. Both religions believed these spirits are able to help or harm, and therefore they should worship them. The attitude of the Native Americans toward nature is respectful, because they have to be respectful to the Supreme Being. They seek to live in harmony with nature. They believe that the earth, the sky, and the waters have a life force similar to that of humans. These forces could be helpful or...

    Read More
    627 Words 3 Pages
  • Native Americans vs. Europeans Essay

    ...Native Americans and European Compare/Contrast Essay Europeans lived a much more modern way of life than the primitive lifestyle of Native Americans. Europeans referred to themselves as "civilized" and regarded Native Americans as "savage," "heathen," or "barbarian." Their interaction provoked by multiple differences led to misunderstanding and sometimes conflict. These two cultures, having been isolated from one another, exhibited an extensive variation in their ideals. Europeans and Native Americans maintained contradictory social, economic, and spiritual practices. The European social structure was heavily influenced by land ownership, with a land-wealthy elite at its center. Europeans viewed land as a resource to be exploited for human benefit. Property was the basis of independence, material wealth, and political status. Native Americans deemed the exact opposite of individual land ownership. Tribes recognized boundaries, like the Europeans, but believed that land was communal. Communal land ownership helped limit social stratification in Native American communities, much unlike the social hierarchy established by the Europeans....

    Read More
    574 Words 3 Pages
  • Europeans vs. Native Americans Essay

    ...America, the Native Americans as they would be called later on in history. For a long time in America's history and even up until I was in Elementary School, it was being taught that Christopher Columbus was in fact the discoverer of America. The truth, as we all know is that he could not have possibly discovered it when there was already people there! Instead, it is possible to say that he "laid claim" to it for Spain. There were many other famous explorers other than Columbus. Some of them include Lief Ericson who discovered Newfoundland, Amerigo Vespucci who discovered South America and the West Indies, Vasco de Balboa who discovered the Pacific Ocean, Hernando Cortez who discovered Mexico and consequently wiped out an entire civilization known as the Aztecs. Juan Rodriguez Cabrillo discovered California while Samuel de Champlain found the Great Lakes and Quebec. The Hudson Bay was named after Henry Hudson after he discovered it. Also, Ferdinand Magellan was the first man to sail completely around the world. At first, the Native Americans welcomed the European Explorers and were curious about them and their motives in their land. The natives introduced the Europeans to gold, silver, potatoes, corn, beans, vanilla, chocolate, many other vegetables and most importantly, tobacco. Europeans did introduce the natives to a few good materials but...

    Read More
    930 Words 4 Pages
  • Essay about Native Americans vs Europeans

    ...In the time of the American Revolutionary War, there were many differences that influenced how our country turned out today. Most of the cultural differences occurred between the Native Americans and the Europeans that had newly settled in what is known today as America. Some of the most notable differences were those of religion, political, economic, and social. These differences divided the habitants of America in several ways and formed many bonds but also brought them to many moments of conflict. When the Europeans landed in America, they sought religious freedom and often tried to convert the Native Americans. The Native Americans as a whole could not grasp the concept of worshiping only one “god”. Native Americans believed that there was a “god” for everything in nature. Though the Europeans believed there was only one “god”, they had many different denominations that were divided into Roman Catholic and Protestant. The only thing that was similar between Native Americans and Europeans, in concerns to religion, was that they both believed in a higher power governing them. Constant pressure on the Native Americans to convert eventually led to King Philip’s War in 1675. In the life of a European, it was...

    Read More
    861 Words 4 Pages
  • Compare And Contrast European Empires In The Americans Essay

    ...European Empires in the Americans: By using the oceanic way, the Western Europe’s places expanded among the Americas, and it conquered most of the lands by the mid-19th century. British, French, and Dutch, which dropped out, are examples of colonies in the North America, and Spain and Portugal were colonies in the South America. The European got benefits from the movement towards the Americas. Their Atlantic states were well placed that they could straightly reach the Americas, which were beneficial since it made it easier to own more lands, to gain wealth, and spread their religion. For instance, as one Spanish conquistador stated that they came to the Americas in order to serve God and to get wealth. On the other hand, The Great Dying was a big catastrophic to the native Americas that highly decreased their population (90% died), and it was due to not having immunities for those diseases that spread after the European came. To illustrate, the population of the central Mexico released from between 10 to 20 million people to only 1 million by 1650. Also, there were exchanges of people, animals, plants, and diseases between the 4 continents which was called the Columbian exchange. One of the big rise of the world was the exchange of potato to the South and North Americas, especially Europeans. Comparing Colonial Societies in the Americas: The Europeans not only conquered the...

    Read More
    760 Words 4 Pages
  • compare and contrast Essay

    ... Comparing and Contrasting “The Story of an Hour” and “How I Met My Husband”. Lora Cruse Ashford University ENG125 11/20/2014 In this essay I will be comparing and contrasting two great short stories. One being “The Story of an Hour” written by Kate Chopin in 1854 and the other being “How I Met my Husband” written by Alice Munro in 1974. The two short stories share the theme of gender roles/marriage. That being said,, I will be going over plot, point of view and tone. Sometimes women feel like they are trapped in their marriage, and sometimes women cannot wait to become married. Kate Chopin's “The Story of an Hour represents a negative view of marriage. Every individual takes a different approach when enduring the loss of a loved one. Whether it is bursting into tears or being miserable. When a wife loses a husband, she typically tends to be in a state of depression. The feeling of losing your significant other is a piercing agony going through one's heart, but in this case the feeling of loss can turn into someone's freedom. For Louise Mallard she had an erratic reaction when she was informed that her husband had been allegedly killed in a train accident. She locks herself in her room and sits in front of the window in desolation. She begins to ponder how her life will be without her husband. The sorrow that Mrs....

    Read More
    1189 Words 7 Pages
  • How Europeans Change the Native Americans Essay

    ...Mercedes Courtenay Professor Hess ENG 241 October 4, 2012 How Europeans Change the Native Americans When Europeans first explored western Virginia in the late 1600s, they discovered few Native Americans. However, their presence, their goods, and their customs had affected many Indians. These changes had shifted the Native Americans and the Europeans in survival, resources, dominancy and rivalry. At the same time, the Europeans had a strong interest in enabling the Indians to acquire valuable new products. Based on various reasons, the Europeans claim territories and Native Americans were forced either leave, become slaves or rebel even more. As result, many of the Europeans and Native Americans were destroyed by the constant warfare. Thus, the European brought attitude and values that reflects their personal desires; conversion, supremacy, and power that conflicted with the native's attitude and values about their customs and belief. The Europeans noticed the native’s lack of knowledge about the divinity of God and use that disadvantage to convert the Native Americans to Christianity to take their wealth. For instance, Christopher Columbus realized that the natives had little to...

    Read More
    1042 Words 5 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free